16/05
2012

With a little help from a site

The UK-based site has the European record for requests

Websites transmitting requests and providing information from official authorities have mushroomed during the last couple of years. The results range from a good start to success. Here's a guidance.

The brits were first out in Europe, and are by far leading by numbers of transmitted requests.
WhatDoTheyKnow.com in the UK (actually England and Wales, Scotland is a different story) has at the time of writing filed 116355 request since the start 2008 to all in all 5761 official authorities.
”We don't yet publish statistics partly because we're concerned about making generalisations and trying to draw conclusions which the data doesn't really support. But we can say that 73,833 have been marked partially or fully successful. Note that the figure for total requests includes all those "in progress", not just those which have been concluded,” explains Richard Taylor, volunteer at the website.
”We have many people from all those categories. mySociey the organisation which runs WhatDoTheyKnow has a focus on making it easier for people to participate in civic life, so we're certainly aiming at the "ordinary people"; the public at large, but overall we simply want to see as great a proportion of FOI requests as possible made in public via our site, so the requests and responses are easily available to the public,” he adds.

Rescued kittens

When asked about interesting information achieved by the site Richard Taylor points at a summery of no less than 366 findings, one for each day for the last year.
Amongst the answers are information about money spent by Kent Council on travels abroad,how much oil the British government keeps in reserve, and how many kittens have been rescued by South Wales Fire Service since 2011 (77), to mention a few.
Measured by numbers of request the German site FragdenStaat.de  (ask the state) probably comes second in Europe although on a somewhat lower scale. Since the start in august 2011 FragdenStaat has transmitted close to 1000 requests, including some multiple request for the same information.
”I think we have had an incredible experience with it over the past few months - it is now accounting for a third of the German FoI requests and has been part in quite a few campaigns. Most users are somewhere between activist and ordinary people not necessarily with a clear political agenda, but with an interest and some persistence,” says system administrator Friedrich Lindenberg.

Results by ikons

At the time of writing 77 request have been given a full answer, for example the costs of conducting a controversial census (counting of people) in 2011 (€ 710 millions). 53 have been partly answered, where as some 300 are being processed, or have been delayed or rejected.
The webpage Anfragen (requests) has a nice and easy way to sort results, with ikons understandable also for non-German readers.
On interesting results Friedrich Lindenberg mentions a request for a paper on corruption of members of the German parliament, produced by a parliamentary research service. The service claimed copyright to prevent its distribution. Then Stefan Wehrmayer, the site's project manager, added a possibility on the site for more people to ask for the same report.
”This was used by about 400 people and created an interesting dynamic, although I'm not sure its effects will be entirely positive,” Friederich Lindenberg says.
(For a more thorough interview about the start and considerations behind the German site, see an interview at the Alaveteli program website)

A right even without a law

The Spanish TuDerechoaSaber.es (“Your right to know”) is an ambitious newcomer on the scene. It is built on the same Alaveteli platform as the british WhatDoTheyKnow, and was launched with the double aims of providing a help to information and to promote a Spanish legislation on access to information.
”Freedom of information is recognized as a fundamental right, so request for access can be done also without a law, just by exercising the right,” says Victoria Anderica campaigner and project coordinator with Access-Info Europe a pro-transparency organisation based in Madrid which helped launch the Spanish site together with civil rights group Fundación Ciudadana Civio
Since the start in March this year the site has transmitted some 400 requests and counting.

Ask the EU

Another Alaveteli-site also based in Madrid is the AsktheEU.org run by Access-info with support from a number of groups and actors from civil society.

Since the launch in September 2011 AsktheEU har transmitted some 100 requests to EU bodies and institutions.
About a third of the request transmitted by AsktheEU have been classified as partially or fully successful.
In 2010 the Commissions received 6127 applications for documents all in all, according to an annual reports on transparency. The Council received 9184 requests the same year.

Besides an online request form and published results from previous inquiries, AsktheEU has also got a Request Guide on how to approach the EU-institutions and what to expect from them.

Interest revealed

A common feature for three of the four sites described above is that filed request are put on the web thus revealing interest for journalists preparing a story before it has been published, or giving hints of what interests a NGO might have for an upcoming campaign.
Richard Taylor at WhatDoTheyKnow, is aware of candid requests might improve the use of the site:
”We have lots of journalists who monitor the site for releases; as we don't offer the facility to make requests in private we do miss out on some requests journalists make themselves and which they prefer to make in private,” he says
The German site FragdenStaat provides a possible embargo, letting reporters file requests and get answers privately and then releasing the material once the story has been published.
”But the press has been reluctant from what I hear, even though we have an embargo, unlike
WhatDoTheyKnow,” Friedrich Lindenberg comments.

None in Scandinavia

Two similar sites up with the same concept are Informatazyrtare.org, in Kosovo and Spinfo.org in Macedonia.

In Scandinavia there are, to our knowledge, no similar sites aimed to help the public at large, partly because access legislation has had a longer tradition with a less felt need to introduce the concept to the public. 

In Sweden tips and tricks of the trade are provided by the Journalist union but on a closed site for members only. The Swedish association for investigative journalists, Föreningen för Grävande Journalister (littterally the association of digging journalists) runs a public site with tools and recent case-law, but in Swedish only.
In Denmark the site Aabenhedstinget.dk (Openness meeting) collects case law, provides good examples and reports on legal news, somewhat in line with wobbing.eu

The Norwegian gateway

Norway is in this respect an interesting story of its own with a official website Offentlig Elektronisk Postjournal (Electronic Public Records) run by the government. The site provides guidance on how to request information, some download possibilities, and a ”shopping basket” for documents, like baskets or charts found at commercial webshops.
The Norwegian site is partly in English. As Norway is closely linked to EU-legislation, although not a member state, the Oep.no can provide a useful shortcut to documents with relevance beyond the Norwegian borders.

Outside Europe - hat tip Toby McIntoch at Freedominfo.org – there are the US-sites FOIA Letter Generator started in 1996 and Muckrock. Civil society sites have also been established in New ZealandChile, and Brazil, wheras the site in Mexico is an official site run by the state and the one in Honduras is run by the country's Information Officer.

Staffan Dahllöf

 
 
 

Wobbing.eu recommends